This article comes from WeChat public account: Zhengjie Bureau (ID: zhengjieju) , Photo by Helloquence on Unsplash
Research master, cannot overcome technical difficulties.
How do I make my sister-in-law study?
I don’t know if you can do it.
However, researchers from the Cold and Drought Research Institute of the Chinese Academy of Sciences, Lanzhou, Gansu, (have been integrated into the Northwest Institute of Eco-Environmental Resources of the Chinese Academy of Sciences) This problem has already been “conquered”.
![]()
1, an odd article
Two days ago, a friend who was doing scientific research in a state key laboratory sent me a paper. At first glance, the title “Theory and Practice of the Integrated Framework of Ecological Economics (I): Understanding of Integrated Thought” is startling and very mysterious.
However, I was almost faint before I finished reading the abstract of my dissertation.
Interested friends can search the original text and appreciate it in person.
In order to prepare you mentally, please read the two comments below.
This article has 25 pages, 22 references, and more than 45,000 words.
Let me help you a little bit.
In addition to the “Introduction”, the article is divided into 4 parts: “Beauty and Tao”, “Teacher’s Sublime Sense”, “Master’s Graceful Sense”, “Life Beauty and Life Avenue”.
The “beauty and Taoism” part has more than 6000 words. After having “philosophical discussions” such as “beauty is life”, “dao is the road”, “big features”, the author finally said to write this article Reason:
Turn the perspective to the mentor and the maid, and sort out their words and deeds according to the ways of seeking beauty and seeking the Tao, and they will find that they are a bright light that illuminates our life.
The following “Teacher’s Sublime Feeling”, this part is obviously the focus, with a total of more than 16,000 words.
Inspecting 3 things from the Qinghai-Tibet Railway, Watershed Science Project, and Watershed Science Project Expert Group Dujiangyan, to unveil the instructor’s “sublime curtain, and appreciate the way of life revealed”.
However, in this process, the author did not simply talk about the mentor, but from here and there, he also demonstrated the mentor and his parents.
Fortunately, the author clicked on the (without us to summarize) The noble feeling of the instructor:
The mentor advocates casting a sword in ten years. His insight is as high and deep as the sky road, and he can easily solve the problem of frozen soil by just cooling the roadbed. The mentor advocates rivers and seas. Calmness, let the heroes nationwide study the soil and water to gather in the Heihe Valley; the instructor advocates the sky to play the pen, his spirit is as mysterious and eternal as time and space, bringing us to the real stage of inheriting this life. Looking at the mentor whose main feature is big, like a rolling green hill, towering in front of me into the sky. The instructor looks down at the world from a height, and observes the image of everything in the world, showing a noble simplicity and solemn greatness. If this does not give rise to a sense of loftiness, it can only be attributed to numbness and lack of understanding.
Below, in the part of “The Beauty of Master and Master”, the author directly said “Master”Motherly beauty, its graceful and graceful style, elegant and pleasant”, but the “beauty sense” of the lady is not just that simple.
The beauty of master-sisters “lurks the beauty of women’s avenues”, specifically, including “women have no talent is virtue”, “it is an obligation to cook for a tutor”, “seeing justice”.
The author’s final summary:
To sum up, the master and wife are able to follow the sea and the sea, which is worthy of being emulated by women and even men today.
Finally, the author incorporates the sense of nobility of the mentor and the beauty of the teacher and mother into a unified analysis system, and outlines a picture of heaven and man, which is the following picture:
Of course, the sublime of the mentor and the beauty of the maiden are different:
Nobleness requires reliance to play with a pen, but gracefulness does not require much thought, but at every point it unconsciously manifests itself as a concept with the instructor as a whole, revealing his heartiness and joy from time to time, Makes people feel close.
In simple terms, the mentor and the maiden acted together to interpret the avenue of life.
In addition, the author hopes to use the avenues of life of mentors and maids to provide reason and reason for establishing an integrated framework of ecological economy.
2, why do professional journals issue “rainbow farts”?
Actually, there is a “sequel” to this article.
To be honest, although I have also received professional academic training, I have n’t read professional papers, and I mainly deal with text after work, but I feel very “tiring” after reading this series of articles.
I can only take a few pictures for your own appreciation.
This article has titles, abstracts, keywords, references, and even English titles. It looks like a professional academic paper.
The reason why it is “unintelligible” is like what netizens evaluate: this is the rainbow fart touting the instructor.
As the saying goes, a hooligan is not terrible, but he is afraid that a hooligan has culture.
Actually, those who do not follow the right path are very scary with culture.
said first issued a document author: Xu Zhongmin.
According to the author’s profile, the author is male, born in 1973, Huarong, Hunan, researcher. He received his Ph.D. from the Cold and Arid Regions Environmental and Engineering Research Institute of the Chinese Academy of Sciences in 2000, and is mainly engaged in ecological economics research.
On the Internet, you can also see some information about Researcher Xu Zhongmin’s lectures.
For example, in November 2014, he went to the School of Geography and Science of Taiyuan Normal University to give a 2014 graduate student a lecture entitled “Everything is the Best Arrangement-Road to Excellence”.
According to the press release, researcher Xu Zhongmin emphasized the role of emotions in change, hoping that students will play a role of positive emotions in their daily learning life, avoid the effects of negative emotions, and pay attention to transforming negative emotions into positive emotions, thereby more Carry out learning and research well.
Furthermore, two consecutive journals of Rainbow Fart have been published: “Glacier Frozen Soil”.
The journal was founded in 1979, the competent unit is the Chinese Academy of Sciences, and the sponsor is the Cold and Arid Regions Environmental and Engineering Research Institute of the Chinese Academy of Sciences. (Cold and Drought) / span>, Chinese Geographical Society.
According to its own website: China’s only academic journal in the field of ice, snow, frozen soil and cryosphere.
Also according to its website, this journal has been awarded the national “Top 100 Scientific and Technological Journals” by the “Top 100 Newspapers” and has been selected as “China’s Most Influential Academic Journal (TOP5%) “.
At the same time, it was also selected as the source journal of Peking University’s “Overview of Chinese Core Journals” and the source journal of CSCD China Science Citation Database (2019-2020) (including Extended version) and so on.
While the author is studying for a PhD, according to a network information in 2017, the Academy is one of the Class A institutes in the Institute of Geosciences of the Chinese Academy of Sciences. ( (7 in total) , which is also the only Class A institute in western geosciences.
So this has to be shocking:
The author with a professional degree, (Get a doctorate from a top domestic institution) , even the only professional journal in the field in China, even connected Post two Rainbow Fart articles!
Also, the article has 35 pages!
Know how valuable this top academic journal resource is today.
Take a step back and say that the Chinese respect the teacher and pay attention to being a teacher for life and being a father for one day.
Especially, after the postgraduate stage, I will pay more attention to teachers.
Respect and be grateful to your mentor. There is nothing wrong with it.
Even in foreign countries, professional journals will publish articles to commemorate experts in related fields, but they are basically discussed from academic contributions, and there is no lack of reflection.
It is rare in China and abroad to use the avenues of teachers and maids like authors to provide reason and reason for establishing an integrated framework of a discipline such as ecological economy.
Besides, “I love my teachers, I love the truth.” Even if the author is 100% in favor of the mentor, and 100% supports it, the article is from the heart, you should also find a supplement to the Metropolis Daily. It cannot be issued as a professional academic paper.
3. This paper is a mirror of magic
Responding to such an odd article, the relevant parties responded quickly.
The journal Glacier hastily issued a statement over the weekend and decided to retract the article.
However, Xu Zhongmin, the author of the media interview, explained:
Natural scientists need emotional injection. The hot discussion article may seem a bit problematic on the surface, but the actual lurking is very profound. It is a great complement to the current geography indulging in science and predicting the future.
I think you, like me, still don’t quite understand the meaning of Xu Bodao’s sentence.
In short, the author thinks there is nothing wrong with this article.
But it is interesting that the target of Xu Bo ’s article praise: Cheng Guodong, academician of the Chinese Academy of Sciences, but told the media that his student (Xu Zhongmin) The two articles published in” Glacier Frozen Soil “are not consistent with the academic positioning of” Glacier Frozen Soil. ”
The academician Cheng Guodong is the editor-in-chief of “Glacier Frozen Ground”.
That is, my students published two articles praising themselves in the professional journals in which they were editors …
Mr. Cheng Guodong also said to this, “After retiring from a leadership position in 2011, I paid little attention to the journal. I did not know about the publication of these two articles in advance, but as the editor-in-chief did not do anything afterwards and should bear Important responsibility. I have formally applied to the leader for resignation, resigned as editor-in-chief, and sincerely apologize to the readers for the adverse effects caused by this! “
However, if we dig a little, we can see that the two seemingly small papers reflect many problems.
First, why are professionals not professional?
Xu Zhongmin holds a Ph.D. and is a researcher and Ph.D. supervisor at the research institute of the Chinese Academy of Sciences.
Slightly searching, you can also find that in “Glacier Frozen Soil”, he also published “The Road to Happiness: The Prologue of the Eco-Economy”, “The Road to Excellence-Change, Persistence, and Eternity”, etc. It has little to do with the research direction of the journal.
Below, it is said that it is a one-page PowerPoint for lectures by Dr. Xu Zhongmin.
If it is true, it will be even more shocking.
Second, why are professional journals not professional?
Glacier Frozen Soil is a self-proclaimed journal in the field of ice, snow, frozen soil, and cryosphere in China.
It also represents China going global.
According to its website, there are currently 9 advisory committee members in this edition of the editorial committee. (3 of them are academicians) . 7 people (3 of them are academicians) , there are 33 editorial members, and 10 international editors, all of whom are professors and researchers job title.
So, let an author send three or four consecutive articles that do not match the positioning of academic journals?
Third, why is this rainbow fart still cited?
According to China HowNet.com, there are 4 papers and 3 master’s theses that quote “Theories and Practices of the Integrated Framework of Ecological Economics (I) .
Among them, 3 of the 4 papers were published in “Glacier Frozen Soil”. Was this intentional in order to increase the citation rate of journals?
The schools from which the three master’s theses originated should get their students back and ask, what inspirations have you got from others’ “sublime sense of the mentor” and “the sense of grace of the teacher” before writing out Thesis? Did you just pull the numbers after reading the title?
4. Rainbow fart, let taxpayers pay? !!
To be honest, this thing wasn’t worth my special article.
It’s like, if the National Football Team doesn’t spend money or finances, and doesn’t stand up to China’s name, it will be how sloppy it will be. I won’t watch it, let alone ignore it.
However, as much as national football, taxpayer money is spent!
When the two articles “Theory and Practice of the Integrated Framework of Ecological Economics” were published, they mentioned that the project was supported by the “National Natural Science Foundation of China (91125019) funding. ”
So, what is this project?
Inquiry from the National Natural Science Foundation project of ScienceNet. This project is called “Comprehensive Research on Water-Ecological-Economic Model of the Heihe River Basin”.
It is also a major research project with a grant of 2 million yuan.
Xu Zhongmin is the project leader. These two papers are part of the results of this project.
So, how much of these 2 million is used to study the sense of loftyness of the mentor and the beauty of the teacher?
Online and online.
Many friends wonder:
In the 1960s and 1970s, under such difficult conditions, we were able to achieve “two bombs and one star” and obtain the Nobel Prize-level research results. (青 Artemisinin, insulin) .
Now, we need a building with a building and a top-level laboratory with a top-level laboratory. Importing sophisticated laboratory equipment no longer needs to cherish foreign exchange. We almost buy it when we need it.
China’s research funding now ranks second in the world, nearly 2 trillion! The state is also constantly looking for ways to create a better environment for scientific researchers.
But now, we still face a lot of “neck neck” technical problems, we can’t overcome them.
Research management is a professional field, and I can’t answer it comprehensively.
But two things are certain:
Fifty or sixty years ago, the “two bombs and one star” heroes, in the vast Gobi, lived in style, and they wanted to serve the country, break the foreign monopoly as soon as possible, and make China’s waistline hard.
To this day, it is impossible to overcome the technical problem of “stuck neck” by studying the teacher.
This article comes from WeChat public account: Zhengjie Bureau (ID: zhengjieju)