Source ｜ Building Studio 8 ( ID: bahaolou-8)
Writing | Liu Na
Title map ｜ Sanlian Life Weekly
On February 2nd, a non-governmental organization airlifted a helicopter to the Xinhua Road Stadium in Wuhan, Hubei Province, and delivered supplies to Wuhan Xiehe and other hospitals, including more than 3,000 sets of protective clothing and more than 24,000 medical masks.
This move directly bypassed the Hubei and Wuhan Red Cross, which have received donated materials since the outbreak.
After accepting a lot of loving materials from the government, enterprises and individuals, Wuhan Red Cross opened Hall A of Wuhan International Expo Center as a temporary warehouse to store materials.
At the same time, first-line medical staff in Wuhan frequently send self-help and help messages on the Internet. They make their own masks, wear disposable garbage bags, send Weibo, and circle of friends saying that supplies are urgent.
Doubts about the Red Cross Society of Hubei Province and the Red Cross Society of Wuhan have continued to ferment. The media and the public questioned the Hubei Red Cross and Wuhan Red Cross materials turnover speed, employee benefits, and their relationship with Wuhan Ren’ai Hospital.
On the afternoon of February 1, the Hubei Red Cross, which was at the center of the whirlpool of public opinion, also responded to some issues. “Hubei Provincial Red Cross Statement on the Distribution of Donated Materials” stated that the distribution of donated materials “is deeply distressed, self-blame and guilty about the problems in the distribution of materials,” the next step will be “painful thinking, inferences, and serious Rectification “.
On February 2, a person in charge of the Red Cross Society of Hubei Province said in an interview with the media that “mainly the pressure on manpower and the psychological pressure.”
For the donation of materials during the epidemic, HuNorthern Red Cross and Wuhan Red Cross are still at the center of public opinion.
Controversy 1: Masks are lost, unfairly distributed?
On January 30, the Red Cross of Hubei Province announced a “Material Use” form, prompting public suspicion.
According to the form, as of the 30th, the Wuhan Red Cross has issued a total of 245,000 masks. Xiehe Hospital (full name of the Union Medical College Hospital of Tongji Medical College of Huazhong University of Science and Technology), one of the 61 hot-spot medical institutions designated by Wuhan, has only received private Donated 3,000 masks. Putian Department Hospital Wuhan Ren’ai Hospital and Wuhan Tianyou Hospital respectively received 16,000 (later corrected 18,000) masks.
The outside world has generally questioned why the private “Putian Hospital” Wuhan Ren’ai Hospital received 18,000 masks, while Wuhan Xiehe Hospital, which has repeatedly rushed, received only 3,000 targeted donation masks.
In a voice of doubt, on the afternoon of January 31, the Hubei Provincial Red Cross issued a correction statement explaining that Tianyou Hospital and Wuhan Ren’ai Hospital affiliated to Wuhan University of Science and Technology sent emergency help information to the Provincial Red Cross and suggested that Participated in the prevention and treatment of new crown pneumonia, and many feverish people awaited medical treatment. In accordance with the objective needs of humanitarian relief and the current state of supplies, it donated 18,000 masks to Tianyou Hospital affiliated to Wuhan University of Science and Technology and 18,000 masks to Wuhan Ren’ai Hospital.
However, the media and the public present another aspect of the truth.
Official information shows that Wuhan Ren’ai is a second-level general hospital focusing on gynecology and obstetrics. According to a visit by a reporter from China Business Daily, Wuhan Ren’ai Hospital does not accept fever patients, and issued an announcement outside the hospital on January 23, 2020, requesting fever patients to go to a fever designated hospital for treatment.
Wuhan Renai Hospital Announcement
In contrast, Wuhan Xiehe Hospital is one of the 61 outpatient medical institutions this time, and it is also one of the places where Hubei Province Municipal Medical Treatment Experts reside. On January 20, the Wuhan Municipal Health and Health Committee announced the list of Wuhan outpatient medical institutions and designated medical institutions, including 61 outpatient medical institutions, including Wuhan Union Medical College Hospital.
As an outpatient medical institution, Wuhan Xiehe Hospital urgently needs medical equipment such as masks. On January 24, Wuhan Xiehe Hospital released the “Announcement and Explanation of Xiehe Hospital’s Acceptance of Love Donations”, which urgently needed all sectors of the society to donate the following protective materials, including goggles, N95 masks, surgical masks, etc., in accordance with laws and regulations. On January 28, Xiehe Hospital announced once again its donation channel for special epidemic prevention and control and donation channels for medical supplies.
Controversy 2: Where did Wuhan Ren’ai Hospital come from?
The donation of 18,000 KN95 masks pushed Renai Hospital to the cusp of public opinion.
Introduction to the official website of Wuhan Ren’ai Hospital, the hospital is a secondary comprehensive hospital based on key specialty of gynecology, obstetrics and dentistry, integrating medical treatment, preventive health care and scientific research. Operating entity.
Caixin and other media have reported that Wuhan Ren’ai Hospital is a “Putian Hospital”. Martial artsXiong Yixiang, the director of Han Ren’ai Hospital, also said in an interview: “Our hospital is indeed a Putian hospital. The Putian department is controversial, but not all Putian hospitals are bad.”
Tianyan Check showed that Wuhan Ren’ai Hospital Co., Ltd. was established in May 2001 with a registered capital of 15 million yuan, and its legal representative is Chen Lixiang, which holds 50% of the shares. Chen Lixiang is also a shareholder and legal person of Wuhan Chengjia Medical Holding Group. According to a report by Hubei Daily in 2017, Chen Zhisong, chairman of Chengjia Group and president of Hubei Private Hospitals Association, is from Putian.
Wuhan Ren’ai Hospital Co., Ltd. and major shareholder Chen Lixiang both received restrictions on high spending in 2019.
Wuhan Ren’ai Hospital has also been accused of being good at “hyping itself.”
The reason is that Wuhan Ren’ai Hospital has been repeatedly punished administratively, including false propaganda in the name of well-known experts, and the use of advertising terms involving medical technology and diagnostic methods. According to the Daily Economic News, Lin Xinru, Yineng Jing, Jia Nailiang, Li Xiaolu, and nursery have all litigated with Wuhan Ren’ai Hospital.
In addition to the “cricket flow”, this hospital also has several intersections with the Red Cross Society of Hubei Province.
Hubei Red Society has cooperated with Wuhan Ren’ai Hospital many times on the issues of “infertility” and “maternal and child health”. The Hubei Daily reported in November 2012 that Wuhan Ren’ai Hospital and the Hubei Red Cross Foundation co-sponsored the establishment of the “Hubei Red Cross Benevolent Relief Fund”. Wuhan Ren’ai Hospital donated 1 million yuan as the start-up fund of the fund.
In February 2016, Jingchu.net published a news entitled “Provincial Red Cross Foundation” Save the Uterine Program “to assist poor gynecologists. On January 30, 2016, hosted by the Hubei Red Cross Foundation, Hubei Red Cross Ren’ai Relief Fund and Wuhan Ren’ai Hospital’s “Save the Uterine Program” was officially launched in Wuhan Ren’ai Hospital.
The article specifically mentioned that in order to implement the special fund, Hubei Red Cross FoundationJin (affiliated to the Red Cross Society of Hubei Province) designated Wuhan Ren’ai Hospital as the “designated assistance center” for the project.
It is worth mentioning that Wuhan Ren’ai Hospital was subject to administrative penalties by the Wuhan Industry and Commerce Bureau for bribery in 2017.
Controversy 3: What are the reasons for slow funding and untimely deployment?
“In theory, the purpose of having the Red Cross is to achieve better donation efficiency. Individual donations have certain costs in logistics and customs.
However, in this outbreak, many hospitals chose to go out for public donations themselves, and donors also requested that the hospitals be directly connected-they would rather bypass official donation platforms such as the Red Cross. Obviously, both donors and hospitals are not satisfied with the efficiency of material coordination and deployment. “People in the industry once said to” Sanlian Life Weekly. “
Distrust of the Hubei Red Cross and Wuhan Red Cross has directly led many donating companies, individuals, and non-governmental organizations to prefer to bear the freight and taxes themselves, and also to donate materials. Individual star studios and fan support clubs also require direct docking with hospitals.
On the evening of January 31, Li Qiang, a member of the party group of the Wuhan Municipal Government, said at a routine press conference on the prevention and control of pneumonia caused by the new coronavirus infection in Hubei, “During the prevention and control of the epidemic, there are many reasons for the problems. One important reason is that the consumption is greater than the supply. In addition, the Red Cross posted the much-needed materials on its official website, but the donated materials and the much-needed materials did not correspond well in terms of variety, model, and standard. >
The Ministry of Civil Affairs issued a document on January 26, designating the Red Cross Society of Hubei Province and the Red Cross Society of Wuhan City as recipients of epidemic donations. In addition to targeted donations, they obeyed the prevention and control of pneumonia caused by new coronavirus infection in Hubei and Wuhan Headquarters unified deployment.
This measure did not solve the problem of lack of materials in Wuhan. “The Red Cross’s material allocation is not timely enough and needs improvement.” Li Qiang said.
Hu Yabo, executive deputy mayor of Wuhan City, said that the core of the problem now is to find ways to achieve accurate distribution and improve efficiency. In fact, many orders were accurately distributed to various hospitals on the plane, but at the scene, it was found that some of the goods were not what we wanted, and some were not standardized.
For material control, Chen Yun, executive vice president of the Wuhan Red Cross Society, believes that “the staff is very tight, there are only a dozen people in the Wuhan Red Society, and more than 20 people in the Hubei Red Society. All of them canceled the annual leave, I can take care of overtime 24 hours a day at the post, and I ca n’t take care of it. “